Asked on the Dog Forum by susanr729 on 9/19/2005, 2:19 pm

Q: Shih Tzu with a hernia

I have a 5 month old Shih Tzu that has a hernia and his heart and liver are in the hernia sac. He has very little lung capacity and has to take a lot of small little breaths. He has been to a vet and to a cardiologist. What are your thoughts on this. His chances, what to expect, what are the best odds? I am trying to make the best decision for him. Thanks
Susan

Answered by Bordterr on 9/19/2005, 11:04 pm

A: Shih Tzu with a hernia

> I have a 5 month old Shih Tzu that has a hernia and his
> heart and liver are in the hernia sac. He has very little
> lung capacity and has to take a lot of small little breaths.
> He has been to a vet and to a cardiologist. What are your
> thoughts on this. His chances, what to expect, what are the
> best odds? I am trying to make the best decision for him.
> Thanks
> Susan
>

..................................

Susan, this is such a unique sort of hernia, so extensive, that probably only 1 to 3 are seen in a high numbers breed like yours in a year in this country (US) This means that only the vets who have examined her and those with experience with this surgery could venture a reasonably accurate estimate of her prospects for surgical repair. I'm afraid that survival prospects without repair are gloomy, but, again, I hesitate to make predictions for time and what he'd go through in that period... his quality of life, which is already limited. The only suggestion that I can make is that if at all possible, a general and thoracic surgery vet specialist should do the repair surgery, and probably at vet teaching hospital with intensive care capability and specially trained and experienced "nursing" staff of technicians... probably at a vet school or a large teaching hospital such as Angell in Boston.

I have to be frank and tell you that many breeders would have had this little tiger euthanized right after birth, or discovery of the extent of major organ involvement, rather than try to keep him alive and well, risk surgical repair, and then see if he would have good quality of life after surgery. Some would have fought tooth and nail to keep him going and growing....

There is no right or wrong decision here. Always keep his quality of life as your focus... and if it will be poor, then do consider loving him enough to release him from his very limited life style, and the heavy burden of continuing to live. You have my thoughts with you as you work through this tough set of decisions.... and a bunch of hugs to use when you need them most.

Answered by susanr729 on 9/21/2005, 11:27 am

Q: Shih Tzu with a hernia

> > I have a 5 month old Shih Tzu that has a hernia and his
> > heart and liver are in the hernia sac. He has very little
> > lung capacity and has to take a lot of small little
> breaths.
> > He has been to a vet and to a cardiologist. What are your
> > thoughts on this. His chances, what to expect, what are
> the
> > best odds? I am trying to make the best decision for him.
> > Thanks
> > Susan
> >
>
> ..................................
>
> Susan, this is such a unique sort of hernia, so extensive,
> that probably only 1 to 3 are seen in a high numbers breed
> like yours in a year in this country (US) This means that
> only the vets who have examined her and those with
> experience with this surgery could venture a reasonably
> accurate estimate of her prospects for surgical repair. I'm
> afraid that survival prospects without repair are gloomy,
> but, again, I hesitate to make predictions for time and what
> he'd go through in that period... his quality of life, which
> is already limited. The only suggestion that I can make is
> that if at all possible, a general and thoracic surgery vet
> specialist should do the repair surgery, and probably at
> vet teaching hospital with intensive care capability and
> specially trained and experienced ''nursing'' staff of
> technicians... probably at a vet school or a large teaching
> hospital such as Angell in Boston.
>
> I have to be frank and tell you that many breeders would
> have had this little tiger euthanized right after birth, or
> discovery of the extent of major organ involvement, rather
> than try to keep him alive and well, risk surgical repair,
> and then see if he would have good quality of life after
> surgery. Some would have fought tooth and nail to keep him
> going and growing....
>
> There is no right or wrong decision here. Always keep his
> quality of life as your focus... and if it will be poor,
> then do consider loving him enough to release him from his
> very limited life style, and the heavy burden of continuing
> to live. You have my thoughts with you as you work through
> this tough set of decisions.... and a bunch of hugs to use
> when you need them most.
>